What is the price of a profit that was never earned? How does one prove the value of an opportunity that never materialised? Unlike expenditure already incurred or payments already made, anticipated profits exist in the realm of what would have probably been. They are anticipatory, in the very meaning of the word. Their recovery therefore presents courts with the delicate task of determining genuine commercial loss especially because our courts are courts of evidence. The difficulty is not simply whether a loss occurred, but how convincingly its value can be demonstrated.
It is this tension that the Supreme Court confronted in National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees v MicroCity Computers Ltd [2026] KESC 79 (KLR), delivered on 30 October 2026. Following the failure of a contract for the design, supply, installation and commissioning of a security system, MicroCity Computers Ltd claimed Kshs 103,447,136 in anticipated profits. The Supreme Court ultimately set aside the award, bringing into focus a fundamental question on the applicable scope and evidentiary standard of proof for awarding anticipated profits as special damages for a breach of contract. More importantly, the decision invites a closer examination of whether the inability to establish the precise value of a loss should necessarily defeat a claim where the fact of that loss has otherwise been demonstrated.
The Dispute
The National Social Security Fund Board of Trustees [NSSF], the Appellant, advertised for a tender in September 2010 for the design, supply, installation and commissioning of a CCTV surveillance and restricted access control system at its Social Security House Complex in Nairobi. MicroCity Computers Limited, the Respondent, [MicroCity] emerged successful and was notified of the award via a letter of the 2nd March 2011. The Parties executed a contract on the 8th April 2011 for a project sum of Kshs 244,825,708/- and an annual maintenance cost of Kshs 15,000,000/- upon expiry of the two-year warranty period.
The project never took off. NSSF did not hand over the site to MicroCity. Instead, NSSF wrote a letter to MicroCity on the 21st May 2012 indicating that it was unable to proceed with the project due to budgetary constraints. Consequently, MicroCity instituted the proceedings at the High Court alleging breach of contract and, amongst other reliefs, sought Kshs 103,447,136 in anticipated profits. MicroCity relied on a financial report titled Statement of Financial Claim dated the 14th March 2017 that assessed fair financial loss occasioned to MicroCity on account of the cancellation of the contract. The Report relied on documentation provided by MicroCity and on projections and assumptions that related to a similar contract in computing the profits that would have accrued had the contract been performed.
While the Court found that NSSF breached the contract and awarded damages, it declined to grant the anticipated profits on the ground that the evidence presented was speculative and fell short of the standard required to prove special damages. Both parties appealed to the Court of Appeal, MicroCity challenging the dismissal of its claim for anticipated profits while NSSF challenged the award of damages. The Court of Appeal upheld the finding on the breach of contract and awarded the anticipated profits on the reasoning that given the unperformed nature of the contract, the assessment of the anticipated profits would only involve estimates and approximations. The Court relied on the financial report and found that MicroCity was entitled to Kshs 103,447,136 as loss of anticipated profits and Kshs 9,056,378 being the aggregate costs in respect of tender preparation and consultancies. NSSF was dissatisfied and appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s Approach
Strict proof does not equate to an impossible evidential burden
The Supreme Court clarified that the requirement to strictly prove anticipated profits does not impose a standard higher than the balance of probabilities. Instead, it demands evidence of sufficient quality and cogency, assessed in light of the nature of the loss claimed. The Court correctly rejected a rigid approach that would require receipts, invoices or payment vouchers for transactions that never took place. This is an important clarification: a claimant should not be denied compensation merely because the very nature of the breach makes conventional proof of expenditure or income impossible. The Claimant ought to produce the best evidence reasonably available.
The Court introduced a conjunctive two-stage inquiry into the loss:-
The Loss-A claimant must first demonstrate that the breach deprived it of a genuine profit-earning opportunity and that performance would probably have generated a net profit; and
The Quantification–what amount should fairly be attributed to the loss.
The Court clarified that the first limb must be established for the court to evaluate the value of the loss.
Expert evidence must rest on proved facts
The Court’s treatment of expert evidence reinforces the principle that an expert opinion is only advisory. The court must interrogate the underlying data, methodology and assumptions rather than accept a report simply because it has been prepared by a qualified professional. The Court ought to interrogate the report inquiring on the material supporting the input, whether the expert tested the findings and whether reasonable alternative assumptions would materially alter the result. Additionally, the burden to prove its claim always rests on the Claimant.
In this respect, the Supreme Court noted that there was a significant variance between MicroCity’s Managing Director’s testimony and the figure cited in the report. The Managing Director estimated the profits at Kshs 26 Million whereas the report estimated the profits at Kshs 103,447,136. Secondly, the Court noted that the report itself stated that its observations were based on assumptions that the information supplied to the accountants was correct and that the accountants were not in a position to verify the information. Thirdly, the Court noted that the expenses used in the calculation related to MicroCity’s operation as a whole and not to the specific contract.
The Court concluded that the material before court did not provide a sufficiently reliable foundation for the specific award of Kshs 103,447,136.
Anticipated profits are not an all-or-nothing claim
The Court recognised that a court is not necessarily confined to either awarding the full amount claimed or nothing. Where the fact of the loss is established, but the evidence does not support the full amount claimed, the court is at liberty to award a lesser amount if the evidence provides a rational basis to do so. The power to estimate is, however, not a licence to speculate. The Court found that neither the claimed Kshs 103,447,136 nor the managing director’s alternative estimate of Kshs 26 million had a sufficiently reliable evidential foundation.
Why this matters
Claimants must keep contemporaneous profit projections and retain the records of similar past contracts;
The experts reports must be premised on factual foundations such as accounts, costs, margins. They should also flag assumptions and test the conclusions against various material variables;
Expert Opinions should be anchored in verifiable facts establishing the fact of loss and quantifying the value;
The Claimant must demonstrate that the breach occasioned a real financial loss which must be supported with the best available evidence;
The court must remain flexible enough to recognise genuine commercial losses, yet sufficiently rigorous to guard against speculative awards.
Whilst MicroCity lost the Kshs 103,447,136 ,the Judgment shall be remembered for striking a necessary balance between compensating parties for profits never earned and ensuring that damages remain grounded in evidence rather than conjecture.
Read the judgment here: https://kenyalaw.org/akn/ke/judgment/kesc/2026/79/eng@2026-10-30


